Ok before people rage on me I'll say this
I know that reuse footage/animation was a common thing in this anime but it does't excuse just how lazy and awful this duel was.

The first problem with this duel was that a good portion of animation use here was reuse from the first duel which is expected considering the show's animation budget but it bad for this one because most of the duel uses this footage almost all of the time even going as far as to reusing almost all of the animation from that duel; of course they to hide the stock footage with cars edited in like any other used of stock footage in the Akio/Apocalypse act Duels but the reuse animation here sticks out like a sore thumb because there is't any new animation for this duel except the ending.

The Second problem was that it was more focus on Juri's duel with Ruka then Utena which should of added a extra layer of tension but failed for the same reason as above; it was Utena first duel with Juri but with two different character and it destroy any tension or enjoyment you could of got out of the duel because(Again) of the lack of new animation or anything that properly distinct it and the duel itself aside from character resolution or story behind it; it shows just how limited Utena's role has been in episodes that focus on Juri character, she was at best a background character in these episode because she really does't have a place in these episode because they focus more on her and the characters that are related to her(Ruka and Shiori)

Because of these two problems; the Duel was really anticlimactic especially if you expect it to be on par with the Utena's first duel with her which had the best theme and animation in it respective story act, what we got is the laziest(and most Disappointing) duel in the entire Tv series on par with chigusa duel in the saturn game in terms of reuse animation.

The saving grace for this duel was the theme and how it ended but it make it worst because you expect the duel itself to be on-par but it everything wrong with the TV show; it takes the shows biggest flaw(Reuse animation/stock footage)& takes it to a new low and it leave a sour taste in my mouth for doing it.
Music-wise: 9/10 great theme that suit the context of situation around the Duel
Animation-wise: 4.5/10 the Duel was a complete mess from a animation perspective thank to it absurd amount of stock footage but the ending to it .
Story-wise: 6/10 it a tense duel in many ways consider the lead up to it but the reason why I did't give it 8/10 or above was because it relation to Utena was limited because she does't have a role in this conflict around shiori and juri so theres no way you could feel in involved in this duel because utena has no proper role in any of episodes the revolve around juri
As a whole: 5/10 my least favorite duel in the series no lies here.