This is a static copy of In the Rose Garden, which existed as the center of the western Utena fandom for years. Enjoy. :)

#1 | Back to Top06-17-2015 08:44:00 PM

LateToTheRevolution
Wakaba Wrangler
Registered: 05-23-2015
Posts: 18

Timeline Confusion

I apologize if this has been asked before but this has recently started bugging me. How long has Utena been attending Ohtori Academy? In the first episode, she already knows Wakaba and already has her verbal sparring matches with the bitchy teacher so it can't be the very first day, yet she needs to be told who the campus head honchos are as if it is her first day. At least I think so, it's been a while since I've seen the first episode. Not only that, but she doesn't know who the school vice chairman is despite just about everyone else knowing who he is. Although, that's probably deliberate on his part. I understand that Utena is kind of dense and off in her own little world but these people are kind of hard to forget. Believe me, I've tried.

Offline

 

#2 | Back to Top06-17-2015 10:59:07 PM

Jacrad
Ballgoer
Registered: 03-25-2014
Posts: 145

Re: Timeline Confusion

Utena was aware of who Touga was.
I can see it, honestly. The vice president usually doesn't have all that much attention called to them so I could see Utena not recognizing him even if she saw him at an assembly or something. Touga also seemed to have more a reputation so that might be another reason Utena was aware of him, it might not have been about his position of authority.

Saionji on the other hand is debatable on whether or not he has any sort of notoriety among the other students. Wakaba has a crush on him and Nanami uses what happened to Saionji as an excuse to sick her minions on Anthy; but I don't recall any other mention of him by students prior to his expulsion.
It's possible that he was just never around the middle-schoolers the previous semesters that Utena was at Ohtori. After all we don't know how long it had been since he had 'won' the rose bride in the first episode. I doubt he'd hang out around middle-school students if it weren't for Anthy presenting herself as one.

I'm not sure if you're talking about Akio when you mentioned the Vice Chairman or not? I think he's technically the acting chairman as opposed to vice chairman.
But I think the same logic I applied earlier of her knowing about Touga because of his notoriety rather than his authority could explain that. Akio probably doesn't have a particularly interesting reputation among the students. Wakaba seemed to know of his existence but had never seen him herself.

Offline

 

#3 | Back to Top06-18-2015 04:28:44 PM

LateToTheRevolution
Wakaba Wrangler
Registered: 05-23-2015
Posts: 18

Re: Timeline Confusion

All fair points, thank you for clearing that up. I did mean Akio. If the real Mr. Ohtori is the main Chairman, then wouldn't that make Akio the Vice Chairman? At least I think so, I don't know how it works in Japan.

Offline

 

#4 | Back to Top06-18-2015 10:21:18 PM

satyreyes
no, definitely no cons
From: New Orleans, Louisiana
Registered: 10-16-2006
Posts: 10328
Website

Re: Timeline Confusion

Mmm hmm, I think Jacrad nailed it!  It's actually really common for someone just finishing SKU to misremember this as being Utena's first year at Ohtori Academy.  Yes, she's oblivious about most of the campus bigwigs -- come on, Utena, didn't you at least notice the high schooler who walks around with green hair?? -- and on top of that, she gets a new dorm assignment.  I wonder whether the first draft of the script had her as a transfer student, as she is in the manga and the movie.

I don't remember what Japanese title is applied to Akio.  I want to say it's just rijichou, chairman, but I'm not sure and I can't immediately look it up.  I wish we had accurate transcriptions of the Japanese dialogue from this show; it would have saved me quite a bit of time over the years. emot-smile

Offline

 

#5 | Back to Top06-18-2015 10:49:38 PM

Dallbun
Tour Guide to Crawling Chaos
Registered: 10-19-2006
Posts: 719

Re: Timeline Confusion

Jacarad is right; Akio is the acting chairman:rijichou daikou, or 理事長代行. He's not the vice chairman because he's not working under the real one: rather, he's doing the real chairman's job.

satyreyes wrote:

I don't remember what Japanese title is applied to Akio.  I want to say it's just rijichou, chairman, but I'm not sure and I can't immediately look it up.  I wish we had accurate transcriptions of the Japanese dialogue from this show; it would have saved me quite a bit of time over the years. emot-smile

Satyr, if you're talking about transcriptions in Japanese, they're right here. Sorry, didn't know you were looking!

Last edited by Dallbun (06-18-2015 10:50:49 PM)

Offline

 

#6 | Back to Top06-19-2015 12:14:16 AM

LateToTheRevolution
Wakaba Wrangler
Registered: 05-23-2015
Posts: 18

Re: Timeline Confusion

I just assumed that Akio was the Vice Chairman because he took over when Mr. Ohtori "fell ill". While we're on the subjects of the Aristocrats' Asian cousins, how much does Mrs. Ohtori know? I assume she's just another pawn who knows just as much as almost everyone else, but you never can tell with this series. She probably assumes Akio is just making a power play. (Which he is, just not in the way she thinks) And finally, I read somewhere (can't remember where) that the reason Akio was marrying into the Ohtori family to gain access to the projector but I have to ask why would they have something like that? I apologize for this going off topic but I figured I'd use this thread instead of starting a new one.

Offline

 

#7 | Back to Top06-19-2015 01:05:34 AM

satyreyes
no, definitely no cons
From: New Orleans, Louisiana
Registered: 10-16-2006
Posts: 10328
Website

Re: Timeline Confusion

Dallbun wrote:

Jacarad is right; Akio is the acting chairman:rijichou daikou, or 理事長代行. He's not the vice chairman because he's not working under the real one: rather, he's doing the real chairman's job.

satyreyes wrote:

I don't remember what Japanese title is applied to Akio.  I want to say it's just rijichou, chairman, but I'm not sure and I can't immediately look it up.  I wish we had accurate transcriptions of the Japanese dialogue from this show; it would have saved me quite a bit of time over the years. emot-smile

Satyr, if you're talking about transcriptions in Japanese, they're right here. Sorry, didn't know you were looking!

Wow, how did I not know about this??  Thank you, Dallbun!  Apparently I should complain more often.  emot-biggrin

Offline

 

#8 | Back to Top06-19-2015 08:40:20 AM

Giovanna
Ends of the Fandom
From: Edmonton, AB
Registered: 10-12-2006
Posts: 8797
Website

Re: Timeline Confusion

LateToTheRevolution wrote:

And finally, I read somewhere (can't remember where) that the reason Akio was marrying into the Ohtori family to gain access to the projector but I have to ask why would they have something like that?

Kanae 'jokingly' suggests that's why Akio is engaged to her, for access to the projector. It can be taken literally, or that she's aware she's using the projector as a metaphor for his position in the school. To be fair, the show does that all the time, anyway. Either way it's the kind of 'joking' comment that is rather pungent with denial given the super obvious insanely affectionate body language we see from Akio in that sequence, who couldn't be placing more distance between them if he was sitting on the opposite couch:

http://ohtori.nu/gallery/var/resizes/Series/Episodes/Black_Rose_Saga/14/Series_ep14_030.jpg?m=1380853279

As for the projector, schools often have complicated and expensive equipment a civilian otherwise can't get at, especially if they engage in active research. (You know, like Nemuro!)

Others already covered Akio's title. I used to think the Vice Chairman was the dumbass guy that hits on Juri in the first arc and then tells Utena to wear short skirts in episode 30 before Akio steps in and strangely enough disagrees. But looks like he's the Vice Principal. (Kyoutou-sensei, it sounded like?) I'm going to assume that's a different set of titles, and that he's not Akio's direct underling. The chairman title implies the boardroom overseer of the school, principal would be the direct administrator over the students. The principal would be the one in charge of disciplining bad students, for example, while the chairman's pumping (ahem) parents for donations and local governments for permission to dominate the rental industry in the surrounding area. In most schools that's one role, but this is a school with international campuses that carries the title of a single family. So he owns the boat, but doesn't necessarily have to steer it. A lot of businesses work this way.*

As for the original subject (lol what?) I always took Utena's apparent ignorance in the first episode to be there to suggest to the viewer how completely unconcerned she is with these things. Wakaba knows the student council well, but never interacts with them. She knows them because she's doing the hero worship thing--Utena doesn't go in for that crap, so she doesn't know them the same way. It does seem likely she'd know Saionji less than Touga--I don't think that's necessarily a lack of exposure, they both get earsplitting screaming in the kendo hall, but she doesn't care about having school crushes either, which I suspects makes people less likely to recognize Saionji. Touga gets around more, in every sense. emot-gonk

*Trust me, I would know! According to an apron I own, I'm the Chairman of the Bordeaux. emot-dance


Akio, you have nice turns of phrase, but your points aren't clear and you have no textual support. I can't give this a passing grade.
~ Professor Arisa Konno, Eng 1001 (Freshman Literature and Composition)

Offline

 

#9 | Back to Top06-19-2015 12:22:40 PM

LateToTheRevolution
Wakaba Wrangler
Registered: 05-23-2015
Posts: 18

Re: Timeline Confusion

More excellent points that will definitely come in handy. And now for round three: I doubt it but is Kanae aware that her family's projector can do way more than set the mood for date night and help her with her astronomy homework? How long have the duels been going on for? The fact that Akio had to seduce his way into the collective pants of the Ohtori family in order to get his current position in the school would suggest that the duels we see in the show are the first iteration. Yet at the same time his insane age suggests that they've been going on for loooooooong time. Unless he was the original founder and has been using the Ohtoris as figure heads all the while seducing his way down the family line, mind wiping when it's needed.

Offline

 

#10 | Back to Top06-19-2015 01:15:23 PM

Enea
Juri Jeerer
From: Poland
Registered: 04-25-2015
Posts: 45

Re: Timeline Confusion

I think that it's all due to the magic in possession of Anthy and Akio. Somehow, the time in Ohtori is not the same as in the real world, as we have learned in Black Rose Arc. In fact, after "Revolution" duel everything could reset. Duellists had probably some sort of reminiscences of their past series of duels.
But I have also another theory, that pleases me more. Characters feel that they were fighting each other more times than they actually did (vide last Utena-Touga duel) and it might be connected with multiverse theory. Like, they were fighting but in different time-lines we don't see in TV series. The existence of them is slightly implied in the movie.

Akio and Anthy are Indians so I suppose that in the past they had lived there and maybe even were some kind of half-gods. They had to flee after mob had attacked Anthy and maybe have gone to the Japan.

Offline

 

#11 | Back to Top06-19-2015 01:54:44 PM

Jacrad
Ballgoer
Registered: 03-25-2014
Posts: 145

Re: Timeline Confusion

I think we can say with pretty good certainty that there have been more duels than the ones we've seen in the series.
The Black Rose Arc explicitly makes mention of 100 duelists that died and Akio says something to the extent of 'This heart sword doesn't work either' when he can't open the rose gate with Utena's sword.

I will say, however, that the 'duels' may not have always come in the form we see in the show. In the Black Rose Arc I was given the impression that the duels came in the form of some kind of battle of knowledge. Where the duelists fought through the success of their research. It's left pretty ambiguous.

But if the duels haven't always been sword fights then it's possible that while Akio might have always dwelled at Ohtori in some form, in his quest to unlock the rose gate, but not necessarily requiring the same level of explicit power. He doesn't necessarily need to be the chairmen to facilitate his goal. He needed to be the chairmen in at least this iteration because his dueling method required that projector. So he manipulated whoever he needed to in order to get what he wanted. It is a rather complicated aspect of the story.

I'll also put this out there. This may have been the first time Akio ever operated outside of the shadows. Yes, he's still pulling the strings as End of the World but he's also actively using his position of power to live luxuriously and to ensure the duels go uninterrupted. The Black Rose Arc introduces him in flashbacks as being in the shadows, literally. And he talks in a way that sounds a lot like a Faustian contract. It might have been that prior to this duel set-up he got his power by striking deals with the leaders of Ohtori and having them act as his arms and legs.

Offline

 

#12 | Back to Top06-19-2015 02:01:20 PM

Giovanna
Ends of the Fandom
From: Edmonton, AB
Registered: 10-12-2006
Posts: 8797
Website

Re: Timeline Confusion

LateToTheRevolution wrote:

And now for round three:.

The short answer, honestly, is that none of it matters, IMO. I very much doubt the projector has any power on its own, and if it exists at all as anything other than a metaphor and panty remover, it's Akio and/or Anthy that made it that way. The path to eternity/whatever is paved, apparently, by the actions of Nemuro, which happen in a vague 'in the past.' I always took this to mean, if we take anything literally, that the projector is created/imbued with whatever capacity it has, at the same time, whether that has anything to do with Nemuro's actions or not. The success of his experiment and the results coincide with what the projector is used for, so I figure it was either made, or 'turned on' then. This is when the dueling game starts, anyway.

Given the heavily implied ridiculous age of Akio and Anthy, I assume they either had some other scheme leading up to this, or that it took this long for Akio to see the need to convince Anthy he's trying to save her, at least in this capacity. There's probably always been some sort of performance to that effect, we just happen to see this iteration. Ultimately, trying to put a timeline to the school, or Akio and Anthy in general, is pretty difficult since the show really only tells us enough for us to make up our own ideas about how old they are. The death of the prince, cynically speaking, could have happened way the hell back in the middle ages, or is something so fundamental it happened in prehistory with the birth and death of the other Jungian archetypes. After the same fashion I don't assume them to be 'genetically' Indian either. I suspect if Akio and Anthy wanted to look Swedish, Nigerian, or whatever the hell else, they'd have that choice.

My headcanon, pretty much totally unsupported, is that the duelists are used and recycled over and over in time--under Akio's influence, apparently no one ages. So the dueling game could be decades old, and who knows--Touga and Saionji might have been fighting over the Rose Bride since the 20's. It would make sense on Saionji's part, anyway. Having met the real Prince and been changed or what have you, they have to graduate now, hence Akio saying he'll start the game over. But I don't assume he's had to do that every time, and maybe he's kept some of that crew longer than others. This is based partly on how old some of the characters act, how much they fit into different time periods (Miki and Saionji especially,) and that there's a riotous confusion of technologies like Ohtori Academy doesn't follow the same rational passage straightforward of time. There are cell phones, so one assumes we've advanced that far, but if Saionji's exchange diary was once delicately worded hiaku with layered meanings snuck to Anthy in the night, would he remember it? Probably not--Akio seems to have the capacity to alter memory where it would result in cognitive dissonance. Which is probably why Touga doesn't remember the powdered wig and heels phase either. emot-rolleyes


Akio, you have nice turns of phrase, but your points aren't clear and you have no textual support. I can't give this a passing grade.
~ Professor Arisa Konno, Eng 1001 (Freshman Literature and Composition)

Offline

 

#13 | Back to Top06-20-2015 12:01:00 AM

Nocturnalux
Qualified Duellist
From: Portugal
Registered: 09-10-2007
Posts: 741

Re: Timeline Confusion

Giovanna wrote:

Others already covered Akio's title. I used to think the Vice Chairman was the dumbass guy that hits on Juri in the first arc and then tells Utena to wear short skirts in episode 30 before Akio steps in and strangely enough disagrees. But looks like he's the Vice Principal. (Kyoutou-sensei, it sounded like?) I'm going to assume that's a different set of titles, and that he's not Akio's direct underling. The chairman title implies the boardroom overseer of the school, principal would be the direct administrator over the students. The principal would be the one in charge of disciplining bad students, for example, while the chairman's pumping (ahem) parents for donations and local governments for permission to dominate the rental industry in the surrounding area. In most schools that's one role, but this is a school with international campuses that carries the title of a single family. So he owns the boat, but doesn't necessarily have to steer it. A lot of businesses work this way.*

I attended one of those 'prestigious schools' for most of my life and can attest that while everyone on campus knew who the principal was, the actual chairman did not even reside in the same country. It is a Catholic school that spans quite a few countries with the headquarters being in Italy and Switzerland. It has been around since the 19th century, from kindergarten all the way to high school my school resembled a palace more anything else and the middle/high school bulding is often mistaken for a palace by tourists. Fun fact, there is actually a secret passage under the theatre bulding, it is an underground tunnel connecting my school but with school opposite it and was built during a time of anti-clerical backlack back in the early 20th century.

I actually got to meet the chairwoman, a very clever and quite liberal minded nun, but this only because I was part of the top students to which she granted an audience when she actually visited the school. Normally the chairman does not interact with regular students at all and I suspect very few would even recognize such a person.

My case was a bit different since both chairman and principal were nuns but there was a very obvious hierarchy, I got to see it firsthand when I saw them together at the audience. The principal was very obviously outmatched and even afraid. Rank is extremely important in such schools as is academic excellence so each branch has to uphold a certain standard. But the chairman was much more tolerant and willing to listen to the students than the principal.
In many ways I was persona non grata so the principal did not exactly like me but the chairman listened to my points with surprising interest. It might be because the chairman has to coordinate so many schools that they do not get as bogged down by minutiae. They give the impression of hovering above mundane issues.

Offline

 

#14 | Back to Top06-20-2015 06:50:13 PM

gpink
Eternal Castellan
Registered: 11-21-2009
Posts: 269

Re: Timeline Confusion

Utena did ask "How many time have we dueled?" during the last duel with Touga. He states three and she remarks that it feels lite it's been dozens of times.

Offline

 

#15 | Back to Top08-26-2015 05:19:26 AM

LateToTheRevolution
Wakaba Wrangler
Registered: 05-23-2015
Posts: 18

Re: Timeline Confusion

Thank you all for the very informative responses and I apologize for being late in responding. I do have a new question however: has there ever been a fan fic that took the whole apocalypse and revolution things and made them a literal occurrence instead of just a ploy by Akio and Anthy?

Offline

 

#16 | Back to Top08-26-2015 05:41:17 PM

Arale
Sunlit Gardener (Prelude)
From: collective human consciousness
Registered: 12-07-2014
Posts: 174
Website

Re: Timeline Confusion

I don't know about fan fic, but do note that the world has ended outside of the school in the movie, and the school itself crumbles with the shadow play girls turning into straw dolls. And the revolution in the show is what gives Anthy (and presumably everyone else) the ability to leave, and even though that's a metaphor for abuse, it can work on a literal level as is as well.

I had a theory I posted on tumblr once about how the world literally ends between the time period Utena enters Ohtori (in the manga) and leaves it (in the movie). Those are the only times the outside of the school is actually shown in present (excepting India which probably was just an illusion anyway) so if you view manga-show-movie as one story, there's a definite parallel between the normal, everyday world of the beginning of the manga and the wasteland at the end of the movie. Since time doesn't move in Ohtori until the revolution (which I place at the end of the show, as Anthy in the manga claims that the revolution hasn't occured yet) it's possible the students literally stayed there until the natural end of the world!!

...is my theory, anyway. but that's pretty literal.


im a shadow play girl irl

Offline

 

#17 | Back to Top08-26-2015 07:55:01 PM

cscratch
Anthy Assailer
From: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Registered: 07-07-2008
Posts: 70
Website

Re: Timeline Confusion

Wow Arale, that is really interesting!!   My mind is blown for the evening in a really good way - thank you! etc-love etc-love

Offline

 

#18 | Back to Top08-28-2015 05:51:59 AM

Arale
Sunlit Gardener (Prelude)
From: collective human consciousness
Registered: 12-07-2014
Posts: 174
Website

Re: Timeline Confusion

Oh yeah I forgot to mention another part of that theory. It's that that is what Akio is taking people to see in his car. "I reveal to you the End of the World" - literally. He's taking them out to the edge of Ohtori to see the apocalypse, to further motivate the duelists into gaining revolution to find out exactly what the hell happened out there.


im a shadow play girl irl

Offline

 

#19 | Back to Top08-28-2015 12:56:29 PM

Atropos
Atropos Turretslayer
From: Hampden College
Registered: 10-22-2011
Posts: 907

Re: Timeline Confusion

This theory sounds familiar.

Wait, I think because it's mine. emot-tongue

Offline

 

#20 | Back to Top08-28-2015 04:36:22 PM

LateToTheRevolution
Wakaba Wrangler
Registered: 05-23-2015
Posts: 18

Re: Timeline Confusion

But isn't there a city (or at least a large town) outside of Ohtori? We see it plenty of times: when Wakaba goes grocery shopping in the episode where Saionji is hiding out in her room, in the episode where Utena and Akio go on their "date", plus we see it in the background whenever Akio takes the duelists on the highway to revolution. Then again, this is a series where we can't trust anything we see and it could all be one insanely big and complex illusion.

Offline

 

#21 | Back to Top08-30-2015 04:24:41 PM

Arale
Sunlit Gardener (Prelude)
From: collective human consciousness
Registered: 12-07-2014
Posts: 174
Website

Re: Timeline Confusion

If its not an illusion, then it could also be just technically part of Ohtori.


im a shadow play girl irl

Offline

 

Board footer

Powered by PunBB 1.2.23
© Copyright 2002–2008 PunBB
Forum styled and maintained by Giovanna and Yasha
Return to Empty Movement