This is a static copy of In the Rose Garden, which existed as the center of the western Utena fandom for years. Enjoy. :)
gorgeousshutin wrote:
The original NGE had blatant rip-offs of Utena too? And in the opening credits? I didn't know that
References to classic science fiction and mecha anime.
The episode with the computer virus Angel was basically The Andromeda Strain WITH A COMPUTER! the Human Instrumentality Project is named after a pseudo-medieval organization in Cordwainer Smith short stories and the details are based on Arthur C. Clarke's Childhood's End, the gory finale is derived from Space Runaway Ideon, Shinji is a gender-flipped version of Nadia from one of Anno's earlier shows, Rei is named after Rei Hino, the backstory is basically every ancient astronauts conspiracy out there...it's a mess of references and allusions to earlier works, and I love the shit out of it.
Offline
Atropos wrote:
Shinji is a gender-flipped version of Nadia from one of Anno's earlier shows
To the 90s NGE creating team's credit, they did do some work to give Shinji a significantly different character design and personality from Nadia (which I've watched). Same with many of the other references in NGE: the creators uses the ref-ed material as the "skeleton", then build something newer (visually and ideally) and at times, more complex out of it all.
That's not the case with what they're doing in Q.
The persistently surviving angel in Rebuild Eva Q has a new design near identical to SKU's Swords of Hate; all the while, it is less ideally-complex (and definitely less meaningful) than the Swords. The swarms of long, sword-like tubes are impenetrable "cores" there as mere plot device, to make sure the Evas cannot shoot through them - there is no deeper thematic / symbolic purpose for their presence, thus they don't incite nearly the same broad range of emotions from the audience. That is a plain ripoff of SKU's Sword Swarm's visual design, nothing more.
Last edited by gorgeousshutin (05-19-2013 10:25:17 AM)
Offline
From the insecure kid with control issues at work: "I'm not the president, I'm the vice president!"
I just stood there and laughed like a maniac.
Also, some of mom's essential oils spilled on my towel in the bathroom. Now I smell like roses. Eugh.
Offline
Touga, I really hope that you aren't talking about this egg, or possibly an even more recursive form of it. But I wouldn't really be surprised. You go to a school named after a phoenix, after all.
Offline
That is... terrifying.
Maybe that's what was in Nanami's egg?
Offline
If Ohtori Academy is the egg the student council has to break through, and then Nanami lays an egg, there's already an egg in the egg. And then there's Saionji's huge pile of eggs.
BTW the first time I saw that episode, Touga's whole 'You're not the kind of girl that lays eggs' thing translated to me as 'You're not the kind of girl that throws tempers.' Because I've always heard the 'don't lay egg' slang and thought that was a reference to that. Then we see Saionji with a massive pile of eggs, because he lays them all the time. I thought the show was being really clever, but looking back I doubt they meant it that way.
Offline
Like I said before, it's all about teen pregnancy.
Offline
This is probably cheating. I was researching, after all. But holy crap.
Insert your favorite duelists.
Offline
Here's an essay on The Catcher in the Rye that reminded me of SKU. (Found it in my first year of high school, just recently found it in my old bookmarks...wow!)
Offline
I didn't like The Catcher in the Rye, but your essay really does have some common themes with SKU. Pretty neat stuff.
Offline
Plasterwork on the side of an old house I stumbled upon.
Yeah, pretty much everything with roses reminds me of SKU. I'm easy to please
Offline
I realize that I wanted the last season of Sherlock to be about the titular character taking back who he wanted to be, rather than basing his identity off of what he thought other people needed from him. Also possibly wearing a girls' uniform.
And that, more often than not, when I'm dissatisfied with a story, it's because I want it to be more like SKU.
Offline
Kita, I know what you mean. I compare every anime I see now to SKU, which means I don't see many of them. It's a tough act to follow.
Offline
Every day, there is a particular task that I do at work. For whatever reason, be it some wild association or just a short-circuiting synapse, I keep getting flashbacks to the dance scene in the Utena movie whenever I do that task. Mind you, there's nothing involved with the task that has anything to do with the scene or the movie. Sure, I wind up leaving work unnecessarily confused, but at least I think of something pretty while I'm cataloging deliveries to a Foot Locker.
Offline
Has anyone ever brought up the parallels between Miki and Kozue and Mozart and his sister?
'Cause, y'know.
Offline
http://www.dezeen.com/2014/08/04/blood- … of-london/
This art piece in London that displayed earlier this month in remembrance for the first World War sorta reminded me of the imagery in Adolescence of Utena.
Offline
Nice picture, Kiseki. That reminds me of a particularly incongruous connection I made to Utena when I visited the National World War I Museum in Kansas City. At the front of the museum there's a glass bridge that leads over a garden of poppies. There are nine thousand of them, each representing a thousand deaths in the war. (That's military deaths only, and a conservative estimate.) They don't look a thing like roses, but I had a momentary vision of the movie's rose garden anyway.
Roses are such ambiguous symbols in the movie. They don't exactly symbolize death, but they sure do grow over the body of a dead prince. Maybe it would be better to say that they represent a pleasant gloss over unhappy realities. Much like, say, looking at nine thousand poppies instead of nine million dead soldiers. Maybe my reaction wasn't so incongruous after all.
Offline
satyreyes wrote:
Roses are such ambiguous symbols in the movie. They don't exactly symbolize death, but they sure do grow over the body of a dead prince. Maybe it would be better to say that they represent a pleasant gloss over unhappy realities. Much like, say, looking at nine thousand poppies instead of nine million dead soldiers. Maybe my reaction wasn't so incongruous after all.
Insightful. I merely correlated the photos as being visually similar to the imagery in the Utena movie... but didn't stop to think about where they grow and why... Glossing over unhappy realities with pleasant or beautiful images... Flowers as symbols in general have such a varied language. Interested how we use them to express so many different things.
Offline
This very conversation we're having about flowers reminds me of episode 35 in which Akio was talking about poppies... Tidbits on native habitat and a legend that poppies grew on a burial site of some figure. Akio was about to talk further about poppies in the language of flowers but the conversation or scene got sidetracked.
Also later in that episode Akio removed a petal of a poppy with his mouth? What does it mean...
Offline
I've been curious about that and looked up poppies in flower language a couple times, but… they don't seem to have a consistent interpretation. Here it's "ephemeral charms," while here it's "consolation" or "fantastic extravagance."
So there's that.
Is there a Japanese language of flowers where it might have a more definite meaning?
Offline
Akio would have explained, but Utena interrupted Goddamnit, Utena.
Offline
Kiseki wrote:
Also later in that episode Akio removed a petal of a poppy with his mouth? What does it mean...
It means I'm crossing my legs tightly and realizing that is enough Internet for the night.
Offline
I wonder if I should move this to the symbolism thread but... Continuing the discussion on poppies, I found a page about poppy symbolism.
http://www.whats-your-sign.com/poppy-symbolism.html
In particular, this info on poppies symbolizing Morpheus stood out to me:
Morpheus lived in his own world - a world of dreams, fantasy and complete nonadherence to traditional reality. He was destined to live here and rule the realms of dreams - it was in his genes. He was born from "night" - his mother is Nix, the goddess of night and dark creations. Morpheus' dad is Hypnos the deific governor of sleep.
To me, this speaks of the potential found in unconventional reality and messages wafting up through our dreams like a sweet fragrance - waiting to be recognized.
The description of Morpheus reminded me of Akio and his rule over the fantastical Ohtori as End of the World.
"Messages wafting up through our dreams like a sweet fragrance - waiting to be recognized" made me recall Utena in the final episodes beginning to recall her real childhood vision that included the suffering Anthy.. that we, the viewer, first saw in her dream in episode 34.
"I kinda feel like I saw a familiar landscape in a dream... I just can't remember."
I swear.. all the meanings people put to flowers.. the things expressed...
Oh! I dug through the forum and found this thread, which also mentioned the poppies! http://forums.ohtori.nu/viewtopic.php?pid=21388
This show continues to be so deep... I can't comprehend how the creators dished out all this information in the show's symbolic imagery in such a relatively short amount of time. So captivating.
Offline
I was watching Project Runway last night and the winning design looked very familiar.
They are not the same, but Juri would rock the later just as she does her's.
Offline
Today I was randomly thinking about eggs which these days often leads me to thinking about the Nanami's Egg episode. But I also recalled a very old episode of Pokemon I watched when I was a child in which Meowth was raising an egg that would eventually hatch to become Togepi. How parental Meowth was in his short time with the egg reminded me of Nanami... and like Nanami, Meowth always had the egg with him..
Bathing with egg...
Sleeping with egg...
Becoming offended when someone suggests the idea of eating eggs...
"What have you done?! How could you eat eggs like that!"
"You brute, brute brute brute brute!!"
Last edited by Kiseki (09-02-2014 10:27:53 AM)
Offline