This is a static copy of In the Rose Garden, which existed as the center of the western Utena fandom for years. Enjoy. :)
Anime has entire genres dedicated to yaoi/yuri, but what about American animation?
Unfortunately, I highly doubt there are many... but they do exist. For example: Lexington of Gargoyles who has been confirmed to be in a gay relationship in the future by the creator, Greg Wiseman. The trouble this poses is that it's only shown in the limited run of the comic... and only hinted at. Gah. (Technically, he is bisexual).
I find that most times, gay/lesbian characters tend to be relegated to the backround in American animation when they exist period. (Fanfiction unluckily doesn't count). They are few and far between and can be outright stereotypes at times.
A very hidden example would be two extremely minor characters in Danny Phantom. Miss. Tetslaff, a walking butch-stereotype lesbian and Bertrand, an older, swishy man voiced in a manner associated with gay men. He even does the wave. I didn't think a green creature could do swish; I was apparently wrong. Neither have been confirmed, but their depictions fit with homosexuality, even if it's a stereotype.
...but would anyone else know of gay/bisexual characters in American animation?
Last edited by Anthiena (02-21-2009 12:29:18 PM)
Offline
I always thought that there was something amiss with Him from The Powerpuff Girls.
Offline
I forgot about Him... he's at least a cross dresser if not flat out gay. Interesting how the animators got away with it...
Offline
I suspect that despite all the politically correct rhetoric about gay and lesbian tolerance, there seems to be an unwritten laws which more or less suggest that openly gay/bi characters in cartoons would lead kids 'down the wrong path' and all that sort of bollocks you expect to hear from moral guardians ands thats why you're not likely to see too many starring gay/bi characters in cartoons anytime soon.
But then again, I never expected to see a black US president in my lifetime either.
Offline
If you're adding comics, there are more examples. Colossus in the Marvel Ultimates imprint for one. There are more, but I just woke up.
Offline
Unlike cartoons, comics should be a different story as comis haven't really been a popular kids medium since the 1970-80s.
In fact. the average age of a comic reader these days is about 25yo.
Sure there are still a few kids comics about (Mostly seen in newsagents and some supermarkets but you go in a comic store and the chances are the kids section is relegated to one little corner while the other 95% of the comics are aimed at readers 15 years and up.
Offline
Enigma is a one-shot Vertigo trade paperback about a gay superhero.
Neil Gaiman has numerous mentions of homosexuality in The Sandman comics, and he deals with it in a very positive way.
Offline
Offline
As I wrote the following I realized I haven't really watched any children's programming in about a decade, so this is likely a dated perception:
Cartoons specifically aimed at children are, I would say, "not supposed to" deal with sex at all. As sexual preference is within that realm, it'd be quite difficult to slip that kind of diversity in. Even heterosexual displays stop at a kiss (usually a single kiss for the whole relationship at that.) If the characters are children themselves, or generally below marrying age, the show can pretend they haven't sexually matured and any affection they have for others is a somewhat platonic puppylove. Even when the characters themselves would have to be biologically mature, just being in a child's show will stunt their emotional maturity.
I agree with Tamago that comics are an entirely different medium, for example you can't find (as a random example) a teenaged boy being graphically eaten by an anthropomorphic alligator on daytime television. (And yet, even though the same comic could feature an openly gay former police detective, full frontal nudity would still not be acceptable.)
So the exception is when comics and cartoons overlap. Batman - The Animated Series had a lot of fun pushing the boundries on what could be shown in an afternoon cartoon show. There were a number of implications that Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy had a physical relationship, making them bisexual at least. This continued on in the rest of the DC Animated Universe, in Superman the character Maggie Sawyer (who is openly gay in the comics) is shown with her female partner while in the hospital, although nothing is stated out loud. By the time the DCAU had moved on to Justice League (and even more so Justice League Unlimited) they were really pushing the envelope though they still refrained from using words such as lesbian. "I hear she's... you know... Brazilian." At the same time, anyone who was, say, eight years old while watching the original Batman TAS series would have been twenty-two by the end of JLU...
Offline
The Authority is a lovely comic book with the main characters Midnighter and Apollo [an offshoot of Batman and Superman, respectively] as a married gay couple, with many pansexual/bisexual characters. What's nice is that they aren't stereotypical, which makes me very, very happy.
Of course, we all know about Batwoman, who was/is in a relationship with the new Question, Renee Montoya in the DC Universe.
Jason Todd is arguably bisexual, but has not been confirmed by DC. [But he probably is, so I'm going to go with that.]
Offline
Same site, next page: http://www.gayleague.com/gay/characters/index.php
Offline
Raven Nightshade wrote:
Same site, next page: http://www.gayleague.com/gay/characters/index.php
...are you trying to steal my thunder? Because that isn't cool.
Also, it seems to me that there are more LGBT webcomics around than actual published comics. I made a list of a few notable ones last year, so I'll look and see if I can find it.
Offline
Adrasteia wrote:
Raven Nightshade wrote:
Same site, next page: http://www.gayleague.com/gay/characters/index.php
...are you trying to steal my thunder? Because that isn't cool.
No, not on purpose, I swear.
Offline
I can't think of any in animation that aren't mere speculation...but as for comics I'd like to add that Renee Montoya (who is the new Question), and Kate Kane (Batwoman) are lesbians.
Offline
Oh yes, I forgot to add that Northstar is gay and he... shows up once or twice in the background during the run of the 90's X-men cartoon.
Comics have lots of homosexual characters (some of whom haven't even been killed off yet!) but they also have, you know, talking Nazi dinosaurs. It's an entirely different category.
Offline
Raven Nightshade wrote:
Adrasteia wrote:
Raven Nightshade wrote:
Same site, next page: http://www.gayleague.com/gay/characters/index.php
...are you trying to steal my thunder? Because that isn't cool.
No, not on purpose, I swear.
I'm just kidding around. I'm not sure my thunder is worth stealing.
Also, this might just be stating the obvious, but doesn't it seem extremely, extremely usual that a sexually repressive culture like Japan's contains more homosexual themes in their pop literature than America's? I've always wondered about this, and can only come to the conclusion that, when people are taught to conserve their sexuality in the public eye, they explode with sexuality when given the opportunity to express themselves.
Last edited by Adrasteia (02-21-2009 08:12:42 PM)
Offline
Outside of corporate comics, gay and/or bi characters aren't really that rare. In corporate comics, as long as it's hint, don't show you can have things like Misty Knight outing herself as bi (and having slept with everyone in the room) or the recent Mary Marvel (possessed by creepy New God of Sadism) is hot for Supergirl bit in Final Crisis. How horrible is it that in Runaways (and its various sequels, miniseries, et al), that Karolina first is condemned only to ever flirt (though, flirt hard, she does) and then she hooks up with a Skrull who argues that ze has no real gender, blahblah, and then stays a male all the damn time? Hint, by all means. Tell, if you have to. For cry-eye don't show don't show!
Warren Ellis has been pretty good in the corporate sandbox for diversifying and allowing demonstratably gay and bi characters, and even simply potentials. Apollo and Midnighter, as already mentioned, though most of their initial black ops team were probably gay (and at least one other, definitely so), but he used a Marvel Comics series to sideways-out The Wasp and have characters discuss how cool it would be if Captain America were gay ("and it would explain why there's always someone dressed as him at pride parades").
I think the lack of range, numbers vs percentage, between American comics and Japanese may have more to do with the larger market in general, in Japan. American comics, luckily, escaped the necessity of having homosexuality end in tragedy (we kept it to film and prose narratives ), but in exchange, American comics never got the recognition - because comics don't in general - when and where they do deal with the topic(s). This is primarily a press issue. American journalism still likes Biff! Pow! headlines, to the detriment of Pedro & Me or The Invisibles, and marketing would prefer to keep a focus tight on sexy gals in Sin City than well-hung fellas and their mourning [male] lovers.
The Enigma is hugely gay/bi/genderfucked as a narrative can get (and brilliant, to boot), but in a culture that even turns Ghostworld into the story of how young impressionable girls get hot for old creepy geeks? Never gonna have a chance.
Last edited by Decrescent Daytripper (02-22-2009 08:02:08 PM)
Offline
ok is batman and robin gay together?
Offline
None of the Robins were "gay with Batman" in canon. That's all speculation. There have been insinuations about Jason Todd, but otherwise, no dice.
Offline
posting solely because this thread is wonderful.
Offline
I might as well be the wet blanket that points out the catch in the Robin/Batman thing is more to do with it being pedophiliac than homosexual.
And I might as well plug that Detective Comics will be running over a year of Batwoman stories soon. Yes, the gay Jewish Batwoman, Kate Kane.
Offline
There have been insinuations that Jinx from the Teen Titans is bisexual, having a fling with Panthra before she died.
Offline
Ragnarok wrote:
Which Robin? Two of them were female, making that difficult.
WHAT?!! okay robin had a brother, a mom and a dad. so how would there be 2females?
Offline